Two steel suppliers send you quotes. Same grade, same specification, same delivery terms. One comes in a little cheaper.
For decades, that was the end of the conversation.
For EU importers, since January 1, 2026, it is the start of one.
Because one of those suppliers may make steel in a blast furnace while the other melts scrap in an electric arc furnace. And the EU’s new carbon border mechanism means importers now have to account for the emissions embedded in what they bring across the border.
The cheaper quote might not be the cheaper steel.
In plain terms: imagine two flights at different prices, where one comes with a baggage fee that only appears at the gate. The ticket price is not the price you pay.
Exporters are already feeling the shift. In the first months of the new rules, one major steel-exporting country saw its shipments to the EU drop by double digits. We will get to that. First, what actually changed?
Table of Contents
ToggleCarbon Just Became a Line Item
The EU’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, or CBAM, has applied under its definitive regime since January 1, 2026. It covers imports in six carbon-intensive sectors: cement, iron and steel, aluminum, fertilizers, electricity, and hydrogen.
Importers bringing in more than 50 tonnes of CBAM goods annually are generally required to apply for authorised CBAM declarant status, subject to specific exemptions.. CBAM certificates go on sale from February 1, 2027, and the first annual declaration and certificate surrender, covering emissions embedded in 2026 imports, is due by September 30, 2027.
Two details matter most for sourcing.
First, the cost depends on the supplier. Importers can use verified actual emissions data from the producer, or fall back on default values set by the European Commission. These default values may include mark-ups, depending on the applicable product and methodology. Missing supplier data can therefore result in higher calculated emissions and increased CBAM costs.
Second, the scope is growing. The UK launches its own CBAM on January 1, 2027, covering aluminum, cement, fertilizer, hydrogen, and iron and steel. The EU is also negotiating an extension to downstream steel and aluminum products, though the final scope has not yet been agreed.
So how big can the gap between two suppliers be?
Same Specification, Different Carbon Cost
Here is an illustrative example using published industry averages. It is not a pricing forecast.
According to worldsteel, steel made through the blast furnace route averaged 2.34 tonnes of CO2 per tonne of crude steel in 2024. Steel made from scrap in an electric arc furnace averaged 0.69.
The European Commission’s published CBAM certificate price for the third quarter of 2026 was €82.32 per tonne of CO2.At that price, the embedded carbon in a tonne of blast furnace steel is worth about €193. For scrap-based steel, about €57. That is a gap of roughly €136 per tonne.
Now the important caveat. These figures represent the gross carbon value, not the actual CBAM liability for 2026 imports. The mechanism is phased in alongside the withdrawal of free allowances under the EU Emissions Trading System. Consequently, only a proportion of the full carbon cost applies initially, increasing progressively until free allowances are fully phased out by 2034. Actual liability also depends on applicable emissions calculations, eligible carbon prices already paid and other adjustments under the CBAM rules.That is exactly why it matters now. Supplier decisions made today – including qualifications, contracts and long-term agreements may remain in place as that cost gap grows.A small price advantage today can quietly become a liability before the contract ends.
And some exporters have already started to adjust.
The Market Is Already Moving
In December 2025, weeks before the definitive regime began, an Indian steelmaker told Reuters: “About 60% of our exports go to Europe and we want to know what is the rate that will be levied and will it be company specific?” Mills were already looking at markets in Africa and the Middle East.
By June 2026, a study by the research institute ICRIER, reported by Business Standard, found that India’s iron and steel exports to the EU were 13% lower in the four months through April, following CBAM’s rollout. The study projected a decline of 24%.
These figures indicate an early market shift, although the decline alone does not establish that CBAM was the sole cause.Those are exporters adjusting. Buyers sit on the other side of the same equation, deciding which suppliers to keep, which to qualify, and which quotes really are cheaper.
For procurement, the important shift is not simply that carbon has become a compliance issue. It is that emissions data is becoming part of supplier economics.
So what should procurement change?
Price the Carbon Before You Award
- Know which spend is in scope. Identify which categories and suppliers involve CBAM goods today, and which could be affected if the downstream extension goes ahead.
- Ask for emissions data in the sourcing event. Request verified installation-level emissions data where available, and make emissions information a standard part of RFIs and RFQs for in-scope goods, not an afterthought at customs.
- Compare landed cost, not quoted price. Add an estimated carbon cost to bid evaluation, with scenarios for future carbon prices and the phase-in schedule.
- Reward suppliers who can prove it. Good emissions data now has a cash value. Treat it as a selection criterion.
Now, the test. For your largest steel or aluminum category, can you name the production route of each supplier? If not, the next section is for you.
Where MeRLIN Fits
Carbon accounting tools help calculate and manage CBAM liability. But the sourcing decisions that influence that liability happen much earlier. This is where MeRLIN comes in.
MeRLIN’s ESG compliance capabilities include configurable surveys and questionnaires that can be associated with sourcing events, whether RFI, RFQ, or eAuction, so teams can request supplier information, including emissions data, as part of how they source rather than after the award. Supplier surveys, a risk register, and dashboards and reporting help keep that information visible across the supplier lifecycle.
Add configurable commodity response templates that capture the parameters affecting total cost of ownership, and procurement has a framework in which carbon information can be considered alongside price, quality, lead time, and risk during supplier evaluation.
MeRLIN helps procurement teams bring supplier emissions information into the sourcing process, compare bids using broader cost and risk considerations, and make more informed award decisions. It supports sourcing decisions; it does not itself calculate or determine a company’s CBAM liability.The cheapest quote is only cheap until the carbon arrives. Put a price on it before you award, not after you import.
Carbon accounting tools help calculate and manage CBAM liability. But the sourcing decisions that influence that liability happen much earlier. This is where MeRLIN comes in.
MeRLIN’s ESG compliance capabilities include configurable surveys and questionnaires that can be associated with sourcing events, whether RFI, RFQ, or eAuction, so teams can request supplier information, including emissions data, as part of how they source rather than after the award. Supplier surveys, a risk register, and dashboards and reporting help keep that information visible across the supplier lifecycle.
Add configurable commodity response templates that capture the parameters affecting total cost of ownership, and procurement has a framework in which carbon information can be considered alongside price, quality, lead time, and risk during supplier evaluation.
MeRLIN helps procurement teams bring supplier emissions information into the sourcing process, compare bids using broader cost and risk considerations, and make more informed award decisions. It supports sourcing decisions; it does not itself calculate or determine a company’s CBAM liability.The cheapest quote is only cheap until the carbon arrives. Put a price on it before you award, not after you import.